I want to run down this trail for awhile longer. There is a lot more to say. We will see how far I get…
I recently had a great conversation with an awesome guy who is getting a Doctorate in Ministry. His degree emphasis is preaching to millennials.
For those of us that don't know what this means - the millennial generation, also known as generation Y, is the generation of folks who follow Generation X. They are people who were born from the early 80's to the early 2000's. While there is no specific date as to when it stops and starts, this is the basic boundary of this socio-demographic.
The explanation of why this matters and the research involved in defining all this is vast and there are volumes written on it. But since it would bore most of us to tears, I want to simply draw some observations about how I believe that the church must respond to this next generation without delving too far into the why. If it resonates, please let me know.
First, and probably most profound for this whole conversation, we have to stop talking about this generation as if they don't care about what is true or what is right. This is neither accurate, nor does it help to further the conversation.
Regardless of what you may think about the way we should understand truth, we live in a world where there is no way to keep from being influenced by a thousand different sources of input in a single day.
I can literally get online and listen and watch the top 20 leaders from any world religion at any moment I choose. And I can also listen to any anti-religious or non-religious speakers as well. My ability to take in information has exponentially increased, and the capacity to process the information has increased as well.
That leads me to my second thought… People are not dumber than they used to be. They are in fact, more aware and more rounded in their perspective than ever. And to try to blow off other points of view simply because they don't line up with your own is foolish and degrading to others.
People can and do process information at a higher rate now than ever in history. But writing and talking at someone are having diminishing affects. That doesn't mean that they aren't important, or that they don't work anymore. It just has less affect than it used to have. And this is due in part to the lack of trust in authority in general in our culture (see my previous blog post). We as a culture are not willing to "take someone at their word" anymore.
Put up or shut up. That is the Modus Operandi of our culture.
These 2 thoughts lead me to a couple of bigger thoughts that are really important as the church moves forward.
First, in order to see the next generation be open to a relationship with Jesus, we have to find a way to keep them part of the conversation long enough for God to get ahold of their hearts.
Prepositional, dogmatic preaching is quickly becoming a thing of the past. And to go back to the beginning of this post, that doesn't mean we have to compromise truth to effectively preach. It means we have to communicate truth better. Beautiful, compelling, inspiring sermons on the foundations of truth and life practice can be done and done well without the preacher turning into an insensitive bully in the process.
And many people will validate that you are "bringing a hard word" and that you "need to give it to us straight." I would suggest 2 things: 1. in relationship, there is no straight - it weaves and winds all over the place. That is the nature of community, and that is what we are asking people to be a part of; and 2. these people that are validating the "hard word" are already Christian. Did your "truth telling approach" bring anyone else to Jesus? Or did it reinforce the lies in people's souls that tell them that God could never truly love someone as messed up as they are?
And I would say that extends even to people who have said yes to Jesus. They might have said yes to being willing to follow Jesus. But do they truly believe that He loves them? Do they truly believe that He sees them as full of potential, not as mistakes or mess-ups. For that matter, do you believe that about yourself? and about others?
I think that for too long, what I would label as "Pulpit bullies" have reigned in our churches. They essentially have approached sermons with an attitude of - my job is to convince you that I am right and that you must agree with me or you are "out." As so there is a lot of pushing and convincing and drawing lines. And to be frank, many of the lines that get drawn are foolish and bound up in tradition not Scripture so they wind up having to get redrawn over and over again. And the church looks foolish because of it.
Second major point - I truly believe that in order to reach the next generation, we have got to stop talking about certain groups of people as if they are second rate. And before you dismiss this point as one you don't struggle with, hear me out.
Over Christmas I got to spend some great time with my family. It was so much fun and probably one of the most memorable Christmases that I have ever experienced. But there were several conversations that caused me to wonder about some things.
Now, my family are all Christians and in ministry. We all love Jesus and we all love the church. And I would say that we all love people from all walks of life. But some of the comments that were made off the cuff about people who are different than us lead me to believe that there are some underlying realities that we are taking for granted.
That which is not intentional is not reproducible. And if we don't intentionally validate and value other people, we will accidentally say all kinds of foolish things about them. And it only drives those who don't know Jesus yet further away from Him.
Nobody said anything intentionally mean. But a few of the statements that were made really made me think about the implications of many of my own statements and how I can say things without thinking that really hurt others.
And people in general have a tendency to do that. We joke and laugh about others that we perceive as weak or weird. It is just like junior high only we are all older. And I get it - I do. I fail at this more often than I want to admit. But our sacred privilege as followers of Jesus is to put our God on display to the world. And those people that we make our careless comments towards are precious to Jesus. So, when we say things off the cuff about other people, it isn't just that we invalidate them as human beings, we also paint an inaccurate picture of our God. And that is never a good thing!
So perhaps the place to begin is with these questions…
How do we determine to intentionally live out being a blessing to EVERYONE around us regardless of their past, present, or how we see their future?
How do we intentionally make sure that the people who come into contact with us are better when they leave than when they came?
How do we invite people into the life transforming relationship with Jesus and keep them a part of the conversation long enough to have it take hold?
Having experienced, as you put it, "Pulpit bullies" recently in a church, it's no wonder the millennial generation want nothing to do with "the church." I'm the generation just before the millennial generation, and fortunately can sort through my association of God with people that are bullies, so know that I need to pick up the pieces and carry on with my relationship with Christ. But, will definitely be steering shy of the people in the pulpit and not laying trust for a very long time in "staff."
ReplyDeleteAaron,
ReplyDeleteI think you made a great point about people of this generation often not being willing to just "take people at their word". Anyone say or write something and post it online as though it is truth. This generation is becoming aware that you cannot trust the majority of what is said in most places.
What do you mean by "Beautiful, compelling, inspiring sermons...."? I have visited a number of churches in the last few years, and most sermons aren't very "in your face" or "straight truth" -- they have often been something I can't really describe. Meaningless, perhaps. Extraordinarily simplistic (1st Cor. 13 right before Christmas = treat people nicer this season). I've honestly found the majority to be a waste of time. I don't know if this is a new trend or if I've just been unlucky. If it is a new trend, I would say that this method is mostly useless as there is very little depth to it. This makes me curious about what you mean by sermons being more beautiful, compelling, and inspiring.
Thanks for posting and getting us to think!
Yes Aaron, thank you for getting us to think. To me this is especially important when I share the Gospel in the workplace - Overly simplistic doctrine can be divisive and drive unbelievers or new believers away from fellowship. A friend passed your blog on to me - I'm going to spread it around. Thanks.
ReplyDeleteAaron, I really appreciate your thoughts on this issue. I find them both very sober and very revolutionary, and I mean that absolutely in a good way. It is really encouraging to see God moving you in the same way He has been moving me.
ReplyDeleteI think the answer to all the questions you brought up is the same, and it's bound up what you said in your first post about presenting the truth better. It’s about living a truth that goes beyond proposition, but is inscribed in the foundations of reality, a truth that reality is actively confirming.
I think the heart of living that is in changing our perspective on truth, as you allude to. I think when we understand that the truest truth, the absolutely objective truth that God sees and knows is above and beyond us, it forces us to realize we can’t define truth. It’s not possible for me to put a boundary on it because I am inside of it. This forces me to look at truth in terms of an approach rather than through the lens of categories and “straight lines”.
That perspective transcends the futile tug of war we play with lies. Whenever we meet lies on their own terms, we make beating the lie propositionally the goal, and make people dispensable units in a war of attrition. The higher truth transcends the “battle”, offering people life, and an eternal escape from the death of whatever lie has hold of them.
By way of example:
The lie of shame tells us ‘you are bad because of what you’ve done’, and the church loves to respond ‘you’re no longer bad because of what God has done’, unaware that we have just confirmed the deeper lie that what you do can erase who you are, who God made you. The higher truth is that you are good because God made you that way, and shame can’t ultimately give a good answer to that, and so the lie falls away.
I think this brings about in any individual, a startling amount of intention, because it is an intentionality built out of the deeper, incontrovertible truth which is within all things.
As a member of the group being discussed, I can say with conviction that precisely what will turn hearts in this generation and get people to be moved by God’s truth, to be drawn intimately.
Hello all... Sorry I have been remiss in keeping up with all your posts. Thanks for all the feedback. I am blessed by your responses. Kari, I think you may be experiencing examples that swing the pendulum too far the other direction. And that certainly exists. What I am talking about is getting deeply immersed in the scripture but not to make dogmatic and careless statements and conclusions. But to inspire us deeper into community and into the text.
ReplyDeleteJosh, I love your example. And I love your point about letting the lie transcend the truth. Or vice versa. Good stuff.
ReplyDeleteThank you. I really have to give credit to the Recovery ministry for that one. They deal with truth and lies on such a fundamentally real level that anything superficial just doesn't cut it. I really didn't 'get it' myself until I got involved with them and started getting serious about how to create and grow accountability in other areas of my life.
DeleteI read your posts about the future of the Church and had to think about it for awhile. Thanks for your posts!
ReplyDeleteIn the first blog post,”Some Thoughts on the Future of the Church…”:
Your observation #1 about people losing trust and respect for authority:
You allude to greed and corruption being a cause for this and I totally agree. I think another big factor is that millennials and others are realizing that people in leadership can be wrong. More and more people are asking good questions, thinking for themselves, and not just taking an authority figure’s word for it. As multiple popular writers among millennials have pointed out, the bible may be inerrant truth, but people’s interpretations(including those in leadership) are not. Being in the medical field, I see this play out in medicine as well: Where people used to take everything their doctor told them as inerrant truth, people today are much more informed and tend to question their doctors’ diagnoses and get second opinions. While many still hold to the bible as complete truth, many now realize that people’s interpretations(pastors or others)of what the bible is actually saying or what was intended are not infallible and open to debate/discussion.
I see the four great points that you make being intertwined and could come down to people just being more informed, critical, and asking good questions.
Point #2 about truth no longer fitting in clean categories:
This may be related to younger generations tending toward taking a fresh look at things, including the bible. They are more likely to let go of traditions and the interpretation of the bible that they were raised on and try to see if it really fits the text. They tend to not see any certain group as having a corner on perfect interpretation.
Point #3 about what motivates people to serve and about younger people not being as loyal to the church:
I feel that this boils down to younger people not being as loyal to institutions. I don’t know that I see them being less loyal to the Church (if Church means the body of Christ) and the world that the body of Christ serves.
THIS STATEMENT THAT YOU MADE IS AWESOME!( If this gets you into hot water with people, I’d love to discuss it with those people.)
“I would suggest that we have to stop measuring the effectiveness of our reaching out into the community based on how many people came to church as a result of it. And I know that will get me into hot water with some, but hear me out on this.
Jesus didn't say be generous in order to grow the church (or the Kingdom). He said be generous because that is what people who are in the Kingdom do. That is how they live. Business measures growth based on investment - R.O.I. The Kingdom measures faithfulness. Growth is God's problem. He says something about that. And yes this is a huge topic, but the point of the church is not to become a great big church. If that happens great, if not, great.
The point of the church is to be a community of people who love each other and give people a picture of what the Kingdom of God really is all about. I will bet that if the church would focus on being the best church for the community and not just the best church in the community - if we would focus on being a place that loves the people within our sphere of influence better than anywhere else, and stop trying to decide how many people came to church because we did such and such…
I'll bet we wouldn't have any trouble at all with growth.”
In the second blog post (this one):
ReplyDeleteI love what you are saying about prepositional, dogmatic preaching becoming a thing of the past and the section about “pulpit bullies” and the “I’m right and you must agree with me or you are out.”
One hang up I have regarding churches in general, and I think this is a big thing for a lot of non-churching going AND church going millennials, is that, even in the churches with much less of the prepositional, dogmatic preaching, there still seems to be some “pulpit bully-like” preaching in regards to tithing. I recently read a book, free online at http://www.truthforfree.com/files/PDF/REK-Tithing3.pdf, that seems to be one of the more exhaustive looks at all portions of the bible that relate to tithing and I think the author has some very good points – not that he has the complete corner on truth related to tithing. My own summary of this book that probably does not do it justice is this: The preponderance of biblical evidence along with the view of the most prominent biblical historians (conservative and liberal) do not agree with the long held and preached view of tithing espoused in many, if not most, evangelical churches.
This may get me into some of that hot water that you mentioned, but it is just my impression, right or wrong. The impression that I have had at a lot of churches goes like this (specifically stated or implied): “Here’s a couple of proof texts related to tithing. You owe this church 10% of your income or you are stealing from God – even though we have no idea how much time and money you give outside of this church to the poor and needy. Also, the details of our operational budget are a secret.”
Ironically, the one church that we attended that did not require a percentage, rarely talked about giving, took in a crazy amount of money and gave an unbelievable proportional amount to benevolence/missions and still had plenty for operational costs. I knew these details about this church, because they were very open about their operational budget. And also, they did not have congregational votes regarding finances or other church issues and still took in a lot of money and distributed it well. For this church, it seemed that more transparency and no voting = more unity, more trust, and more giving.
So, here’s some hard questions: It seems clear that God asks us to sacrifice our finances and time, accept a lower standard of living, and give to the Church and those who have need. Is the 10% tithe a negotiable or non-negotiable for church doctrine? Does it apply to everyone regardless of income(including legitimately poor people)? Should church givers know the details of where the money goes? How do churches best encourage giving without a dogmatic approach? Will you do a blog post on tithing/giving at some point?
Thanks, Aaron, for creating a place for this ongoing conversation! I love this stuff! You are addressing some current issues that really need attention.
Hey Dustin, thanks for the idea… it has in fact, prompted a new post.
ReplyDeleteAaron,
ReplyDeleteThanks for getting me thinking, You nailed it for me, very personal and needed insight